Home » Comparisons, Hauls, Vintage

Essie Dominica Green Dupes and Weekly Haul

20 August 2010 642 views 12 Comments

Can you believe I have made it through a whole week of posting?! Yay me! If I can bang out a review or two for BMovieChicks.com, this will have been my most productive week in the last few months!

First of all, I finally got to putting together another dupe for you all, and I didn’t go easy – I’ve pulled out all the stops for this one… Prepare to have your mind blown out your patootie because ESSIE DOMINICA GREEN HAS DUPES, YO.

Dominica Green Dupes
Nat Robbins Greed, Essie Dominica Green, Finger Paints Sketch & Etch

Dominica Green was my white whale for a LOOOONG time. I was lucky enough to snag a bottle for $20 from a friend who was downsizing and I swear it felt like all my Christmases had come at once. I’d really like to see Essie re-release this colour, but I’m not holding my breath. But if you are without the great Dominica Green, fear not because for $5 or less you can have something close enough to fool even the most discerning eye.

Essie Dominica Green Nat Robbins Greed
Essie Dominica Green, Nat Robbins Greed

When I stumbled across Nat Robbins Greed for $0.99 on eBay, from the pictures it just looked like another pretty emerald green. Imagine my surprise when it arrived! I knew straight away that I was looking at Dominica Green in another bottle. I probably would have near on fainted if I didn’t already own DG.

Dominica Green Dupes
Index & Pinky: Nat Robbins Greed, Middle: Essie Dominica Green, Ring: Finger Paints Sketch & Etch. Taken with Flash.

Sketch and Etch is close, but is ever so slightly more frosty. The base colour and transparency is the same though. Honestly I can not spot a single difference between Nat Robbins Greed and Essie Dominica Green. Same amount of coats, same consistency, same amount of frost, same shade… They even SMELL the same. Could Nat Robbins and Essie been one and the same at some point in time? Were leftovers of the Dominica Green batch sold from Essie’s manufacturer to Nat Robbins on the cheap? I definitely think it is one the the two, because Greed & DG are not the only Essie/Nat Robbins twins. There’s also Nat Robbins Midnight Hour, which is eerily close to Starry Starry Night… But more on that later.

Weekly Haul
Sally Hansen Prisms Ruby Emerald, Maybelline Pink Pizazz, Maybelline Purple Punk, Sally Hansen Prisms Rainbow Presents

The no-buy (low buy) is going well! Above is my eBay haul for the week – and it all came from one seller! My fave of the bunch would have to be Rainbow Presents. How cool is it? What a great name for a polish too.

Unnamed Polish

I found these while I was out shopping today at an odd little stand in the middle of Narellan Town Centre that had a whole bunch of weird stuff like tacky jewellery, lighters, hand soaps and toothpaste. They have no names or anything, but they were only $3 and the colours are great!

Finally I wanted to show you a couple of frankens that I just built for a swap request.

Frankens

On the left is “Teenage Vixens from Outer Space”. It’s blue diamond, red square and purple square glitter in a black holo base. “Four Past Midnight” is a 50/50 mix of China Glaze Nightfall and Silver Glitter. Essentially its a purple Starry Starry Night. I hope my swap partner is happy with these!

Have a great weekend everyone!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • Zygzak

    Hi
    Thirst I must say thay I have been reading your blog quite long and I love it. I’m a polish collector, I love especially greens.
    Now to the subject. I do not have Dominica, but I managed to get greed (and midnight hour too) and comparing with essie photos didn’t see any difference. I also have another possible dupe, it is sensique earth, almost exactly the same (98%) as Dominica, only needs 2 coats instead od 4. I can send you a photo, but I can’t find your email adress.

  • Kaz

    Wow! I have never heard of that brand! You can email me at kaz@pretty-random.com

  • zygzak

    It was supposed to be first not thirst, can you correct it?

  • Meg

    Wow – those greens are identical to me! You got some great colors from that ebay seller – especially Rainbow Presents. Yay for mutlichrome!

  • aaminahs mom

    nice post–now i have the fingerpaints etch n sketch so i’m good i’m sure you know fingerpaints released another green in the autumn hues fall 2010 called harvest hues and its a bit darker green still really close.i know i will never get the essie dg so its good to have these dupes(jus for the record i bought 2 etch n sketch)

  • Kaz

    Yep! I have Harvest Hues as well. It’s like a darker Sketch N Etch!

  • Kaz

    I know! Can’t wait to try Rainbow Presents!

  • Tjoyu

    Awesome dupe post! And those glitter frankens are great!!

  • Kaz

    Thanks love!

  • MissMidnightBlue

    I am kicking myself for not getting Ruby Emerald. I do have Rainbow Presents though I love it!! I know you will!! I think I just might put that on tomorrow.

  • Kaz

    I wish that Sally Hansen hadn’t discontinued the prisms! They were fantastic!

  • Pingback: Naily News #43 | You've Got Nail