If I had an obsession with any vintage Halloween line, it would have to be Fantasy Makers, Wet & Wild’s Halloween line. Fantasy Makers are still around to this day, more recently seen in the bottles with the cool “RIP” headstone caps. I love that Wet & Wild get into Halloween so much that they have their own sub-brand to accomodate it! Here’s my collection – I’ll start with the newest ones first.

These two are still fairly recent but I’m not sure where they came from. They don’t look like part of the regular line.

These Fantasy Makers are a little older, no idea how old though. In my collection, there’s two different kinds of cap – brushed silver and holographic. I’ve seen gold holo caps too but I don’t own any of those. I just picked up Mystery, Hot Blooded and Jack-O from eBay, but I’d love to get my hands on Fiery (orange shimmer), Night Crawler (light purple creme) and Shinin’ (pale blue shimmer). I originally thought that the ones missing the ‘g’ off the end of their name were a single collection, but I have a mix of brushed and holo caps so who knows? No matter what their story, these are awesome.

This last lot look more like the traditional tall cap Wet & Wild bottles, just with black caps instead of white. I just added Yellow Creme, Black Red and Orange Creme to my collection, but I’d still love to get my hands on Green Glam and Passionate Purple. I’m sure there are many others as well.

This last one is a complete mystery. It was a gift from a friend, and while it bears the same name as the Green Glam that I saw on Polished Claws Up, it’s completely different! I’ve never seen anyone else with this polish, nor have I ever seen it for sale anywhere!

I can’t wait to add more of these to my collection. Do you have any vintage Fantasy Makers that I haven’t mentioned?